MCAT vs USMLE Step 1: What Carries Over and How to Get a Head Start

By Dr. Ray Makar, physician and USMLE tutor

Many premed students see the MCAT as a wall to climb and then forget. But as a USMLE tutor, I can tell you that a big part of what you learn for the MCAT comes back two years later on USMLE Step 1. If you study the MCAT the right way, you are already building your foundation for medical school. In this article, I compare the two exams and show you exactly what carries over.

MCAT vs USMLE Step 1 at a Glance

MCAT USMLE Step 1
Who takes it Premed students applying to medical school Medical students (usually after year 2) and international medical graduates
Purpose Admission to MD and DO schools Medical licensure in the United States
Length About 7.5 hours, 4 sections About 8 hours, 7 blocks of up to 40 questions
Scoring 472–528 Pass/fail (since January 2022)
Question style Mostly passage-based Clinical vignettes (short patient cases)
Main subjects Biology, biochemistry, chemistry, physics, psychology, sociology, reading Anatomy, physiology, biochemistry, pathology, pharmacology, microbiology, immunology, behavioral science

What Carries Over from the MCAT to Step 1

1. Biochemistry (the biggest overlap)

Amino acids, enzyme kinetics, glycolysis, the Krebs cycle, the electron transport chain, fatty acid metabolism, and DNA replication all appear on both exams. On the MCAT you learn how the pathway works. On Step 1 you learn what happens to a patient when one enzyme is missing. For example:

  • MCAT: Which enzyme is the rate-limiting step of glycolysis? (Phosphofructokinase-1.)
  • Step 1: A child has hemolytic anemia after eating fava beans. Which enzyme is deficient? (Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase.)

Students who truly understood the pathway on the MCAT find the Step 1 version much easier.

2. Physiology

The MCAT covers the heart, lungs, kidneys, hormones, and nerves at a basic level. Step 1 builds directly on this: cardiac cycle, pressure-volume loops, acid-base balance, and the renin-angiotensin system. If you can explain why blood pressure rises when the kidneys sense low flow, you are already halfway to a Step 1 answer.

3. Genetics and molecular biology

Mendelian inheritance, Hardy-Weinberg, DNA repair, and gene expression are tested on both exams. Step 1 adds the diseases: for example, defects in DNA mismatch repair cause Lynch syndrome.

4. Psychology, sociology, and ethics

The Psych/Soc section is not “extra.” Learning theories, defense mechanisms, sleep stages, and social determinants of health all return on Step 1 in behavioral science and ethics questions.

5. Reading and reasoning (CARS)

Step 1 questions are long patient stories. The reading discipline you build for CARS (find the key point, ignore distractors) helps you read vignettes quickly and accurately.

6. Statistics

Basic research methods and data interpretation on the MCAT become biostatistics on Step 1: sensitivity, specificity, study design, and bias.

What Is New on Step 1

Some subjects are mostly new in medical school:

  • Pathology: how diseases change cells and organs.
  • Pharmacology: drug mechanisms, side effects, and interactions.
  • Microbiology and immunology: bacteria, viruses, fungi, and how the immune system responds.
  • Gross anatomy and clinical presentation: what a disease looks like in a real patient.

Physics and general/organic chemistry, on the other hand, play a much smaller role on Step 1. You will rarely need to calculate anything with physics formulas.

How to Use Your MCAT Prep to Get a Head Start

  1. Study for understanding, not memorization. For every fact, ask “why?” Understanding lasts; memorized lists disappear after the test.
  2. Keep your biochemistry notes. Many students throw them away after the MCAT. Keep them. You will use them again in year 1.
  3. Connect every pathway to a disease. When you learn the urea cycle, look up one disease caused by a defect in it. This is exactly how Step 1 thinks.
  4. Practice with question banks, not just reading. Active practice is the best way to learn for both exams.
  5. Do not burn out. Rest after the MCAT. Medical school is a marathon, and you need energy for it.

Try a Step 1-Style Question

A 6-year-old boy develops dark urine and pallor two days after eating fava beans. A blood smear shows bite cells and Heinz bodies. Which enzyme is most likely deficient?

  1. Pyruvate kinase
  2. Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase
  3. Hexokinase
  4. Phosphofructokinase-1

Answer: B. Glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase. G6PD makes NADPH in the pentose phosphate pathway. Red cells need NADPH to keep glutathione in its reduced form and protect against oxidant stress (such as fava beans or certain drugs). Without it, hemoglobin is oxidized and forms Heinz bodies, and the spleen removes pieces of the cells (bite cells). Notice how this question uses MCAT-level biochemistry and adds a patient.

Want more questions like this? See our practice questions for medical students and the Repeated USMLE Questions collection. Still preparing for the MCAT? Read What Is a Good MCAT Score in 2026?

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the USMLE harder than the MCAT?

Most students find Step 1 harder because it covers far more material and expects clinical reasoning. But Step 1 is pass/fail, while the MCAT is scored. Both need serious preparation.

Does a high MCAT score predict passing Step 1?

Studies have found that higher MCAT scores are linked with better performance on Step 1. But your habits in medical school matter much more than your MCAT score alone.

Should I start studying for Step 1 before medical school?

No. Enjoy your break. The best preparation is to finish your MCAT with strong understanding of biochemistry and physiology. Start formal Step 1 prep during your preclinical years.

The Bottom Line

The MCAT and USMLE Step 1 are different exams, but they share a foundation: biochemistry, physiology, genetics, behavioral science, and careful reading. Study the MCAT for understanding, and you are not just getting into medical school. You are getting ready for it.

About the author: Dr. Ray Makar is a physician who practiced dermatology for 20 years and has tutored medical students and doctors for the USMLE for many years. He is the author of the “Repeated USMLE Questions” book series on Amazon.

Leave a Comment